2024-08-23

Alarm at the pool

 

Image from Pixabay

In the past, 100 to 150 children drowned every year in France. A significant portion of these tragic accidents occurred in private swimming pools. That is why legislation was introduced in 2004 requiring safety measures. The number of annual drownings in private swimming pools fell to 20-50.

Nowadays, French private swimming pools must have a fence, cover or alarm system. During the holidays we encountered the latter, which was intended to alert parents if a child falls into the water. The owner of the house had explained to us how it worked: hold down one button on the remote control, then press the other and voilà, the alarm was turned off and the pool was open for business.

If you forgot to turn it off and jumped into the water, you were treated to a loud alarm sound just a moment later. Then someone had to quickly grab the remote control and press the buttons. It soon became apparent that this did not work properly: only after several attempts did the alarm go silent. It was unclear what was wrong. A light came on on the remote control, so apparently the batteries were still good. The buttons were soft and vague to the touch, so you tended to press harder and harder. Perhaps the circuit board under the buttons had become damaged over the years. Anyway, this couldn't go on any longer.

Fortunately, there was an alternative. There was a magnet in the garage with which you had to touch the alarm box in the swimming pool to switch off the alarm. That worked flawlessly and saved us from a lot of hassle. Although sometimes things still went wrong, because if no one had been in the pool for fifteen minutes, the alarm was automatically activated. If you didn't think about that at the next refreshing dive, you were still in trouble.

The lights on the alarm didn’t really help, either. There were two of them: one red, the other green. If the green light was on, you were not allowed to swim, and if the light was red, you were all right. From the alarm’s point of view, I get it: if the alarm is on, the swimming pool is protected, and therefore the green light is on. Alarm off means unsafe, so red. But from the user's point of view, this is not convenient, because one usually crosses the road when the light is green.

No concerned neighbors showed up on the doorstep in the event of a (false) alarm. They simply lived well out of earshot. But what would this be like in a more densely built-up environment? I don’t think that the entire neighborhood would show up with swimming rings and rescue hooks at the first beep. Only if the alarm continued, a slightly irritated neighbor might perhaps come and take a look. But isn't it already too late then?

And yet the legislation appears to be quite effective. I think that a sturdy fence with a child-resistant lock works best - preventive measures prevent misery, while detective measures only signal that there is a (possible) problem. Prevention is better than cure; not being able to fall into the pool is better than having to be fished out half drowned.

I could make a clever link to my field of expertise here, but you get the idea yourself. Automatically throwing away a phishing email before it ends up in your inbox causes less hassle than clearing up the mess after you have clicked on that link. Blocking access to a rogue website is more effective than having to respond to a malware infection. Not asking your customer for data that you don't actually need is more sympathetic than having to inform your customer that their data have been leaked - yes, sometimes not doing something is also a measure.

Of course, this is not a disqualification of all those security systems that signal that something may be wrong. We really need that too. Defense in depth means that you build up protection in layers. If someone has left the pool gate open, an alarm system can still prevent a lot of grief. Just as it is very important that you recognize phishing and handle it correctly - in case the security systems fail to catch it. It's a shame that French legislation only requires one measure.

 

And in the big bad world...

 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Water distress

  Image generated by ChatGPT Apeldoorn (the Netherlands), Friday 4 October 2024, 18:22 – 70 thousand households receive a mail bomb: the tap...